How to Use Anal Toys for Beginners — A Complete Melbourne Guide
How to Use Anal Toys for Beginners — A Complete Melbourne Guide
If you've been curious about anal toys but aren't sure where to start, you're not alone. Anal play is one of the most searched topics in the adult toy world — and one of the most misunderstood. The good news is that getting started is genuinely straightforward when you have the right information, the right toy, and the right approach.
This guide is written specifically for people who are new to anal toys. It covers everything from the basics of why anal play is pleasurable, to which toy to start with, exactly what to do step by step, what to expect, and how to avoid every common beginner mistake. By the end you'll know more than most people who've been using anal toys for years.
Quick links:
- Why anal play feels good — the anatomy
- The rules beginners must know
- Choosing your first anal toy
- Step-by-step beginner guide
- Our top beginner picks in Melbourne
- Common beginner mistakes
- Frequently asked questions
Why Anal Play Feels Good — The Anatomy
The anal area is one of the most nerve-dense regions of the human body. The external anal sphincter alone contains hundreds of nerve endings, and the surrounding perineum, internal sphincter, and rectal walls are all richly innervated with the same sensory nerve fibres that make other erogenous zones pleasurable.
For people with a prostate — the walnut-sized gland located approximately 5–7cm inside the rectum against the front wall — anal stimulation can directly stimulate the prostate, producing intense orgasms that many describe as unlike anything achievable through other means.
For people without a prostate, the nerve endings in the anal area connect to the same networks as clitoral and vaginal tissue. Anal stimulation during other sexual activity stimulates multiple nerve networks simultaneously, which is why many people find combined clitoral or penile and anal stimulation significantly more intense than either alone.
The stigma around anal play has no relationship to how widespread it actually is — survey data consistently shows it's practiced regularly by a large proportion of the population across all genders and orientations.
The Rules Beginners Must Know
Rule 1 — Always use a toy with a flared base or retrieval cord
This is the single most important rule and it has no exceptions. The rectum can draw objects inward and there is no natural stopping point as there is in the vaginal canal. A flared base — a wide, flat base that sits flush against the body — physically prevents a toy from being pulled inside. Every anal toy sold at Sex Toys Melbourne has a flared base or retrieval cord. Never use anything anally that doesn't have one.
Rule 2 — Always use anal lubricant
The anus doesn't self-lubricate. Friction without lubricant causes discomfort and can cause micro-tears in the delicate tissue. Dedicated anal lubricant — thicker and longer-lasting than regular lube — is not optional. It's the difference between discomfort and pleasure. Always use water-based lube with silicone toys.
Rule 3 — Pain means stop
A feeling of pressure or fullness is normal. Mild discomfort during initial insertion as the sphincter adjusts is common. But pain — sharp, burning, or increasing discomfort — means stop, remove the toy slowly, and reassess. Pain is never something to push through in anal play.
Rule 4 — Start small
The most common beginner mistake is choosing a toy that's too large. Start with something that has a maximum diameter of no more than 2–3cm. You can always progress to larger sizes over time. Starting small makes the first experience comfortable and pleasurable rather than overwhelming.
Rule 5 — Clean your toys thoroughly after every use
Anal toys require thorough cleaning after every single use without exception. Non-motorised silicone toys can be boiled or dishwashed. Motorised toys should be cleaned with toy cleaner and warm water according to their waterproofing rating. Never share toys without full sterilisation between uses.
Choosing Your First Anal Toy
The best first choice: a small silicone butt plug
A small silicone butt plug with a flared base is the ideal first anal toy for the vast majority of people. Here's why:
- Size — small plugs (2–3cm diameter) are manageable for beginners
- Shape — the tapered tip makes insertion easy; the neck grips in the sphincter to stay in place
- Material — silicone is soft, flexible, body-safe, non-porous, and easy to clean
- Passive — no vibration means you can focus on getting comfortable with the sensation of insertion and wearing before adding more complexity
- Affordable — quality small silicone plugs start under $25
Consider a training kit
If you think you'd like to progress to larger sizes over time — or if you're not sure where to start — an anal training kit with three graduated sizes (small, medium, large) is an excellent investment. The Adam & Eve Anal Rockets Trainer Set is our top recommendation, giving you a structured progression path from one set.
What to avoid for your first toy
- Anything without a flared base (never, under any circumstances)
- Large toys (you'll regret it)
- Porous materials like jelly rubber or PVC (unhygienic)
- Vibrating toys for your very first time (add vibration later, once you're comfortable with the basics)
- Anal beads for your very first time (wonderful toys, but a plug is a better introduction)
Step-by-Step Beginner Guide
Before you start
Use the toilet and rinse the anal area with warm water. You don't need to use an anal douche — it's a personal choice, not a requirement. Most beginners find a simple rinse is sufficient. If you want more thorough cleansing, browse our anal douche range.
Step 1 — Get fully aroused
This is the single most important step for beginners and the most commonly skipped. When aroused, the anal sphincter naturally relaxes, the body produces natural lubrication in surrounding tissues, and the entire area becomes more sensitive and receptive. Attempting to insert a toy without arousal is much harder and less pleasant than inserting it when fully aroused. Spend meaningful time on foreplay, masturbation, or whatever produces arousal for you. Don't rush this.
Step 2 — Apply anal lubricant generously
Apply a generous amount of dedicated anal lubricant to both the toy and the anal opening. Then add a little more. There is no such thing as too much lube for anal play. Water-based anal lube is the right choice for silicone toys. Browse our anal lubricant range.
Step 3 — Start with external stimulation
Before attempting any insertion, spend 1–2 minutes massaging the external anal opening with a lubricated fingertip or the lubricated tip of your toy. This relaxes the sphincter, introduces pleasurable sensation to the area, and prepares the body for insertion. The external sphincter is a voluntary muscle that tightens in response to perceived threat — this step signals that what's happening is pleasurable, not threatening.
Step 4 — Insert the tip slowly
Position the tapered tip of the plug at the anal opening and apply gentle, consistent inward pressure. Exhale slowly as you begin — exhaling relaxes the pelvic floor muscles and significantly eases insertion. Don't thrust. Don't force. Apply steady pressure and let the body open around the toy naturally. If the sphincter resists, pause, breathe, and wait. It will relax.
Step 5 — Insert to the neck
Ease the toy in until the widest point passes the sphincter and the neck sits in the sphincter. The plug will settle naturally at this point — the sphincter grips the neck and the flared base rests against the body. This is the wearing position.
Step 6 — Pause and breathe
Once the plug is in place, pause and breathe. The initial sensation of fullness can feel intense, particularly for first-time users. This typically settles within a minute as the body adjusts. Take this time to breathe and relax into the sensation rather than immediately doing anything else.
Step 7 — Continue with other play
Once comfortable with the plug in place, continue with whatever else you had in mind — masturbation, partnered play, or simply exploring the sensation of the plug worn during movement and arousal. Many first-time users are surprised at how quickly the initial fullness becomes pleasurable rather than just unusual.
Step 8 — Remove slowly
Remove by gripping the base and applying gentle outward pressure. Bearing down slightly (as if having a bowel movement) relaxes the sphincter and makes removal easy. Remove slowly. Never rush.
Step 9 — Clean immediately
Clean your toy immediately after use. Don't leave it.
Our Top Beginner Anal Toy Picks — Available Now in Melbourne
All ship same-day to Melbourne on orders before 2pm AEST in completely plain unmarked packaging.
INYA Prince Small Butt Plug — $19.99
A slim, beginner-friendly silicone butt plug at $19.99 with a convenient ring pull for easy removal — particularly reassuring for first-time users. The ring pull doubles as a retrieval mechanism and a handle, making removal straightforward and confident. 11.5cm total, tapered tip, body-safe material. An excellent first plug.
11.5cm • Ring pull retrieval • Tapered tip • Body-safe • Beginner size • $19.99
Small Butt Plug Clear — $28.95
A classic beginner butt plug in clear body-safe material — smooth, tapered, with a wide flared base. Simple, effective, affordable. The clear finish makes it easy to inspect for cleanliness. Available in clear, purple, and pink — all the same design in different colours.
Classic shape • Wide flared base • Body-safe material • Easy to clean • Beginner-friendly
Small Butt Plug Pink — $28.95
The pink version of the classic beginner plug — same shape, same body-safe material, same wide flared base, in a soft pink finish. A popular choice for those wanting something a little more aesthetically playful than clear.
Classic shape • Wide flared base • Body-safe material • Pink finish • Beginner-friendly
Adam & Eve Anal Rockets Trainer Set — $69.99
Three graduated silicone butt plugs in one set. Start on small, progress to medium and large at your own pace. Removes all guesswork from the progression journey. All three have flared bases, body-safe silicone construction, and the classic tapered shape. Our most recommended beginner kit.
3-piece graduated set • Small, medium, large • Body-safe silicone • All flared bases • Best value kit
Shop Anal Rockets Trainer Set →
Common Beginner Mistakes — And How to Avoid Them
Choosing a toy that's too big
The single most common beginner mistake. Bigger doesn't mean better when you're starting out — it means uncomfortable. Start with something small (under 3cm diameter) and work up. There's no rush and no prize for going big immediately.
Not using enough lube
The second most common mistake. More lube is almost always better. If something feels like friction, more lube is the answer. Reapply during use if needed — lube absorbs over time.
Skipping the arousal step
Trying to insert a toy without being fully aroused is like trying to run without warming up. The body isn't ready. Spend meaningful time getting aroused before attempting insertion and the difference is dramatic.
Tensing up instead of relaxing
The sphincter tightens in response to perceived threat. If you tense up or try to force the toy, it will resist. The key is to exhale, relax the pelvic floor, and let the toy enter at the body's own pace.
Rushing removal
Remove slowly. Rushing removal can cause discomfort. Grip the base, bear down gently, and ease the toy out slowly.
Not cleaning the toy immediately
Always clean immediately after use. Don't leave it for later.
Using the wrong lubricant
Regular lube is thinner and less long-lasting than dedicated anal lube. Use anal-specific lubricant. Water-based only with silicone toys. Browse our anal lubricant range.
What to Expect From Your First Experience
Honest expectations are important. Here's what most beginners actually experience:
The good: A sensation of fullness that, once the initial adjustment passes, becomes distinctly pleasurable for most people. Many beginners are surprised at how quickly the "this feels weird" shifts to "this feels good." Adding anal stimulation to masturbation or partnered sex often produces noticeably more intense orgasms even on the first attempt.
The neutral: The initial insertion may feel like some pressure. There may be a sensation similar to needing the toilet, particularly for first-time users. This is normal and passes quickly.
The less good: If you've started too large, used too little lube, or haven't gotten sufficiently aroused, it may be uncomfortable rather than pleasurable. This isn't anal play being "not for you" — it's technique. Adjust the approach and try again.
Frequently Asked Questions for Beginners
What is the best first anal toy for a beginner in Melbourne?
A small silicone butt plug with a flared base — 2–3cm maximum diameter. The INYA Prince ($19.99) is our top value pick with its convenient ring pull. The Adam & Eve Anal Rockets Trainer Set ($69.99) is the best option if you want a structured progression path.
Does anal play hurt?
It shouldn't — when done correctly. Pain means something is wrong: insufficient arousal, insufficient lubricant, too large a toy, or too much force. With appropriate arousal, generous lube, a correctly sized toy, and patience, the experience should be comfortable and pleasurable.
Do I need to use an anal douche before playing?
No — it's a personal choice, not a requirement. The lower rectum doesn't typically contain faecal matter unless you're about to have a bowel movement. A simple warm water rinse is sufficient for most people. Douching is available as an option if you prefer it — browse our anal douche range.
Can anal play cause permanent damage?
No, when done correctly. The sphincter is an elastic muscle. Appropriate use with correctly sized toys and without force does not cause permanent damage.
Is anal play only for certain types of people?
No. Anal play is enjoyed by people of all genders, all orientations, and all experience levels. The anatomy that makes it pleasurable is the same in everyone.
What lubricant should I buy for my first anal toy?
A dedicated water-based anal lubricant — thicker and longer-lasting than regular lube. Browse our anal lubricant range for the right options.
How quickly does delivery to Melbourne take?
Same-day dispatch before 2pm AEST. Melbourne metro 1–3 business days in plain unmarked packaging.
Explore Our Beginner Anal Toy Range
- Shop anal beginner accessories Melbourne
- Shop all anal plugs
- Shop all anal toys Melbourne
- Shop anal lubricants
- Shop anal douches
Ready to start? Visit Sex Toys Melbourne — Melbourne's biggest online adult store. Discreet delivery across Melbourne and Australia-wide. Australian owned since 2002.